I was recently asked why I didn’t write more about other forms of writing. Why I so often wrote and blogged about the “gold standard”. Did I not think other ways of writing were important? Well yes I do, but this post is by way of a bit of an explanation.
Academic writing is a changing. Or so some say. The evidence produced for this claim is the plethora of new genres of writing that academics now do.
It’s not just peer reviewed papers and scholarly monographs, edited collections and encyclopaedia entries any more. We now routinely see poetry, plays, short stories, novels, novellas, comics, posters, films, TV programmes, posters. And art installations, exhibitions and performances. We also have op-ed pieces, blog posts, zines, podcasts, websites, essays, long magazine articles, columns and articles for particular publics in their publications. Oh and of course press releases, policy briefings, you tube clips and texts for the various socials.
I love this variety. And I do play in some of these places myself. But there is a down side to all of this textual innovation.
You see most of us are expected to be over a fair few of these new forms. Pretty exhausting if you’re a new scholar to get on top of all of these textual possibilities. But it’s also exciting to think that you might turn your hand to something other than the bog standard paper. So how to reconcile the challenge and the drain.
The problem is that the bog standard paper is still expected in most (but not all) disciplines, and particularly in places where there are audits of “outputs” as well as institutional emphases on citations as both measures of individual academic “productivity”, and also faculty/school status and institutional reputation. Most academics in most disciplines, in most faculties, and in most locations still have to turn out some of your basic default academic publications. And then they get to play afterwards.
It’s doubly or triply tricky if you’re precarious. Selection panels will be impressed by blogging and podcasting, but most still also want the standard fare. The REF-able as its called here in the UK, after the name of the national university audit programme, the Research Excellence Framework. Emerging academics are expected to show they can and already do have publications that can be submitted for this ranking ritual.
But all of us also have to do enough of the new stuff to contribute to the institutional profile as well as establish ourselves as good institutional players (yes, read this as the push to become an exemplary new neoliberal academic hell bent on furthering career and reputation by churning out texts and grant applications). We do the orthodox and the new, the trad and the boundary pushing. There really is little choice but to take on some of the alt. It does count for getting jobs And it counts in getting promoted. And the alt might well turn out to be the most pleasurable part of the work. So we can – should?- certainly engage with it.
However we ought not, IMHO, to think that the academic publishing ground is going to shift away from the bog standard text any time very soon. As long as the current emphasis on producing auditable texts continues, and there are league tables of institutions and individual academics ranked by H index, then the default peer reviewed journal and scholarly monograph will prevail. Even if big publishers were to take a hit because of open access, other larger policy changes would need to happen to make all our more obviously creative work count more.
That’s not a reason for not experimenting, for developing skills in alt forms of writing, for engaging in the socials, for writing for popular outlets. It is simply to say that we ought not to make too big a claim for the imminent transformation of the academic reading, writing and publishing economy. And that therefore most of us will need to continue to hone our writing in the default genres.
Having said that, I will take a turn to the less auditable text next year, even if just for a bit. Alt texts to kick the year off.
Patter is now taking a tiny bit of leave and will return in the new year. I wish you and yours all the best for the festive season.
Photo by Jonathan Farber on Unsplash
Have a blessed Xmas and New Year…thanks for all your wonderful posts which have been passed on to many of my students and coilleagues.
Thank you. You too.