a new pen

I recently bought a fountain pen. I’m not sure why, as it was expensive, and I don’t seem to have a lot of call for such a pen.

Now, it’s not that I don’t write by hand. I do. A lot. As an ethnographer I am always taking notes when I’m “in the field”. However, I usually use a biro, or sometimes a pencil or two. I’m quite fussy about the biros and pencils; I like them to have a certain weight. I don’t like a writing instrument that feels as if it might blow away. I want something solid in my hand.

If I’m going to sketch something, which I also often do in ethnographic research, I like to have a black ink pen handy – you know, the kind that leaks when you’re on a plane. I’ve often mistakenly left a black ink pen in my bag and then covered myself in a hard-to-wash-off inky mess when I next take the lid off. Maybe that’s happened to you too.

IMG_0188

Like a lot of people I keep handwritten notes of meetings in a diary-style notebook. There are generally lots of ‘to do’ lists in those books, often with far too little crossing out as things actually do/don’t get done… But I wouldn’t use a fountain pen for this kind of meeting work. Too pretentious perhaps, or just too easy to lose the pen!

I’m really not sure why I bought this particular fountain pen and at this time. Some kind of nostalgia, perhaps, for an era when I used to write most things by hand?

I’ve been musing recently on how writing may have changed with the advent of the computer. I don’t mean just the act of typing, but the actual processes of composition. Although I’m a planner, I think that I planned a lot more when I wrote by hand and then typed up the nearly final version. It’s so easy with a computer to cut and paste, to remove things and to re-order.

I can remember going into a creative writing class to show students my own hand-written version of cut and paste… it was not unusual for me, pre computer days, to physically cut up a text and stick it back together with tape. So my manuscripts not only had pages with lots of scribbled insertions, arrows and crossing out, but they also usually only hung together thanks to Richard Drew (he invented Scotch tape). The students were often amazed at the amount of revision that went on before the final copy was typed – and that of course was the point I wanted to make.

odour-b2

I too am often amazed by the amount of revision that some writers do. I am particularly interested in the way that some writers kept revising and revising their galley proofs. D H Lawrence for example, treated his galley proofs as if they were simply the next version of the story for him to work on. I can only imagine what his publisher thought of the expense of having to typeset and then re-typeset and then re-typeset again.

(See the full text and more about Lawrence and the writing/production of the story The Odour of Chrysanthemums here.)

But I don’t have someone else to type out my manuscripts, I must do this myself. And academic writers are not given the luxury of making substantive changes to their manuscripts after they are set. We have to keep changes to a minimum. So we are accustomed to having to get our revisions done before we submit our work. And writing on a computer does in fact save one of the steps – rather than write by hand and then type, we type and can revise much more easily on a computer, we don’t have to redo the entire manuscript each time.

Perhaps then this is not why I bought the pen.

The anthropologist Tim Ingold suggests that writing by hand is a ‘making’ similar to playing an instrument, or crafting an object (Ingold, 2007). Hand writing requires more of the body than simply typing. It has a physicality which requires

… continuous flowing gestures not a sequence of discrete letters.
In a cursive script the line, as it unravels upon the page, issues directly from this gestural movement, with all the care, feeling and devotion that goes into it. I compare it to practising my cello. When I practise – which I do as often as I can – the sound pours out from the contact between bow and strings. In just the same way, handwriting flows from the moving point of contact between pen and paper. The keyboard ruptures this connection. The tapping of my fingers on the keys bears no relation to the marks that appear on the page or screen. These marks carry no trace of movement or feeling. They are cold and expressionless. Typing on the computer, I find, is joyless and soul-destroying. It rips the heart out of writing.”
(Ingold on handwriting)

Ingold says that he encourages his students to write by hand in order to reawaken a sense of personal involvement in authoring which, he suggests, can lead to different and often profound insights. There’s a pleasure arising from the act of writing itself, rather than just from the production of text.

Maybe it is the act of writing itself that I want to get back to. I used to like handwriting as a child. I enjoyed the aesthetics of a neatly written page, and the pleasures of copying out texts I liked. Maybe this is what I want to try to recreate.

As yet, I don’t know. My new fountain pen sits in its box, waiting for me to discover what use I have for it. We will see.

PS. If you too want to wonder about when to use a fountain pen like mine, and can afford this luxury, then they are sold online.

About pat thomson

Pat Thomson is Professor of Education in the School of Education, The University of Nottingham, UK
This entry was posted in academic writing, fountain pen, revision, Tim Ingold and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to a new pen

  1. Apples says:

    I LOVE a good pen – and I always find that handwritten notes stick in my head much more than anything I type!

    Like

  2. I confess to being a fountain pen addict. I have 6 in a pot on my desk at present – plus one with an extra broad nib and highlighter ink. Each pen is slightly different in size and weight – and is filled with a different colour of ink. I virtually always write initial drafts by hand – and use a fountain pen for working with printed typed drafts. Yes, I do have pencils and ballpoints as well, but I love the fluidity of real ink in a good quality pen. It is worth looking for a good quality coloured ink that fits with the use you want to make of the pen – I have found Herbin and Diamine ranges good – and particularly like the ‘imperial purple’ and ‘lie de thè’ but tend to use ‘lierre sauvage’ for everyday – I purchase from various suppliers online.

    Like

  3. Bob says:

    Call me old-fashioned but I find a fountain pen to be ‘proper’ writing. I have a wonderful old pen for general notes and draft writing, a cartridge fountain pen for out and about, and another with red ink for editing of my drafts – I use a lot of red ink! They are a joy and, for me, an encouragement to write.

    Like

  4. James Pickles says:

    I always draft and plan by hand, then type up later.

    Your post made me reflect more on why I do this. It is not because of a romantic attachment to handwriting. If anything it is frustrating having all my thinking on paper rather than in a digital document, because it is not searchable and easily lost. The reason I do it is that I can’t think by typing, whereas I can think by writing. I can make any marks I like on paper, externalising my thoughts more easily. Also writing on paper feels less final, and that feeling gives me more freedom to write something down, without worrying about getting it down right.

    Like

  5. I totally get this, Pat! I love a bit of retro writing or sketching for that reason of investing in and connecting to the work in a tangible, physical way. And as James says, thinking through writing.
    When I went to New York on a work trip I was all about the old school tools – https://theeduflaneuse.wordpress.com/2014/10/07/travelling-toolkit/ – although I also blogged. Enjoy your pen!
    Deb

    Like

  6. Jane S says:

    I’m glad you’ve joined the club of modern retrogrades, Pat. We’re a goodly company, not at all inferior!
    I inherited my late mother’s Lady Sheaffer pen. Black Parker Quink had dried in the ink sac, but by chance there happens to be a fountain pen repairer in the next village. (I don’t see this as a likely future career option for today’s techie generation, do you?!)
    Air travel leakage can be solved: swap the internal ink sac for cartridges, and keep them separate for the journey. (Odd we’ve come full circle there. László Bíró invented the ball-point pen the RAF took up for writing at altitude but Biro didn’t make a fortune. That fell to Bic, Parker *et al*.)
    My bugbear is poor quality paper. You can’t write on cheap stuff, esp. the recycled variety ~ ink just bleeds across the page. Also, my handwriting’s suffered from lack of use. Virtually constant keyboarding doesn’t help one to retain fine motor skills, but unfortunately I touch-type far, far faster than I can write by hand.

    Like

  7. maelorin says:

    I write best when I write with a fountain pen. I have several. I carry a pair of transparent Lamy pens (AUD$50 each) and two boxes of ink cartridges (one purple, one blue-black), along with an A4 notepad, pretty much everywhere. I use cartridges in my travel set to avoid/minimise leakages. (FWIW There is a high-end brand of fountain pens that has a device for emptying pens and refilling them, specifically to address leakage on planes!)

    The tools we use shape the way we use them. I find I write differently with a fountain pen than with a roller-ball. The pen feels different to hold, and to use. Good tools do matter.

    Like

  8. wanderwolf says:

    I used fountain pens all through high school. It was perhaps, a lame way to seem cool amongst my nerdy friends, but they are also easy to come by in Europe (everyone has them and they range from 7-30-100 Euro) and I liked the way I wrote with them

    Like

  9. wanderwolf says:

    Also, I revise very similarly. When I wrote my BA Thesis, I printed out my draft and spent week with a sealed work room, making sure no one could come in to disarray all the scraps of paper ordered across the floor. 🙂 it is interesting how composition has changed since the advent of the computer

    Like

  10. Pingback: There’s something to be said for good Fountain Pens | ORGANIZING CREATIVITY

  11. Pingback: a good notebook | patter

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s